Are Personal Loans Bad?

When personal loans can be genuinely helpful

Sometimes a personal loan is the least bad option among imperfect choices. If your alternatives are tapping into your 401(k) (which can cost you 10% in penalties plus taxes plus lost compound growth), taking out a payday loan (with exorbitant fees), or allowing a critical situation to worsen, a personal loan at even a moderately high interest rate might be the responsible choice.

Here are some examples of when a personal loan can be more beneficial than harmful:

Consolidating high-interest debt

• The most compelling use case for personal loans is consolidating existing high-interest debt, particularly credit card balances. If you’re carrying $15,000 in credit card debt at 24% APR and can qualify for a personal loan at 12%, you’re cutting your interest rate in half. This isn’t just about saving money on interest—it’s about creating a clear path out of debt.

• Credit card debt is revolving, meaning minimum payments are designed to keep you in debt for years or even decades. A personal loan converts that open-ended obligation into a fixed repayment schedule with a definite end date. The psychological benefit of seeing a countdown to being debt-free shouldn’t be underestimated. Moreover, making one fixed monthly payment instead of juggling multiple credit card bills simplifies your financial life and reduces the risk of missed payments.

Covering genuine financial emergencies

• When faced with a true emergency—major medical expenses, urgent home repairs, or unexpected car repairs needed to get to work—a personal loan can be a lifeline. The key word here is “genuine.” Replacing a failed water heater in winter qualifies; buying a new TV doesn’t.

• In emergency situations, personal loans are typically preferable to alternatives like payday loans (which can carry effective APRs of 400% or more) or depleting your retirement accounts (which triggers taxes, penalties, and permanently reduces your retirement savings).

• While it’s true that an emergency fund is the ideal solution, the reality is that many Americans don’t have adequate savings set aside. When emergencies strike without an emergency fund in place, a personal loan can prevent a temporary setback from becoming a long-term financial catastrophe.

Financing major life events strategically

• Some life events require upfront costs that, while planned, may exceed your available savings. Medical procedures not covered by insurance, fertility treatments, or adoption costs are examples where personal loans sometimes make sense. These are significant, often life-changing expenses that shouldn’t be taken on lightly, but they also represent situations where the benefit clearly exceeds the cost of borrowing.

• Similarly, some career investments might justify a personal loan. If you need to relocate for a job opportunity that will significantly increase your income, or if you need to cover expenses during a career transition that will improve your long-term earning potential, borrowing might be strategically sound. The key is ensuring the future benefit substantially outweighs the cost of the loan.

When personal loans are a mistake

Funding lifestyle inflation

• One of the most problematic uses of personal loans is financing lifestyle upgrades you can’t actually afford. Taking out a loan for a vacation, wedding beyond your means, or luxury purchases is essentially borrowing from your future self to enjoy something today. Unless your income is about to increase substantially, you’ll be making those loan payments with the same salary that couldn’t afford the expense in the first place—except now you’re also paying interest.

• This becomes particularly insidious because the easy availability of credit can mask the reality that you’re living beyond your means. Each loan payment reduces your available monthly income, making it harder to save for the next expense, which creates a cycle where you might need to borrow again.

Consolidating debt without changing behavior

• Debt consolidation only works if you address the underlying behavior that created the debt in the first place. If you consolidate $20,000 in credit card debt onto a personal loan but continue using those now-paid-off credit cards, you’ll end up with both the personal loan payment and new credit card debt. This is worse than where you started.

• Studies show that a significant percentage of people who consolidate debt with personal loans end up accumulating new debt within a couple of years. Without a budget, spending plan, or commitment to understanding what led to the debt accumulation, consolidation just provides temporary relief before making the problem worse.

When you can’t afford the payments

• This should be obvious but bears stating explicitly: never take out a personal loan if you can’t comfortably afford the monthly payment. “Comfortably” means after covering all essential expenses and with some buffer for unexpected costs. If meeting the loan payment requires everything to go perfectly in your financial life—no car repairs, no medical issues, no unexpected expenses—you cannot afford that loan.

• Defaulting on a personal loan damages your credit score, can result in the debt being sent to collections, and may even lead to legal action. Some lenders can garnish your wages if they obtain a judgment against you. The short-term solution becomes a long-term problem that’s worse than what you started with.

Borrowing for rapidly depreciating assets

• Using a personal loan to buy a car, boat, or other vehicle is generally unwise because these assets lose value quickly. While auto loans exist specifically for this purpose and typically offer lower rates because the vehicle serves as collateral, using an unsecured personal loan with a higher interest rate for a depreciating asset compounds the financial inefficiency. You’ll likely end up owing more than the item is worth for years—a situation called being “underwater” on your loan.

The hidden costs beyond the interest rate

When evaluating a personal loan, the APR is just the starting point. Many lenders charge origination fees, typically 1% to 8% of the loan amount, which are deducted from the funds you receive. So a $10,000 loan with a 5% origination fee means you receive $9,500 but owe $10,000 plus interest.

Late payment fees, returned payment fees, and prepayment penalties (though these are increasingly rare) can add up. Some lenders also charge application fees or fees to receive your funds quickly. Read the loan agreement carefully and calculate the total cost of borrowing, not just the monthly payment.

There’s also an opportunity cost to consider. The money going toward loan payments each month is money that can’t be invested, saved for emergencies, or used for other financial goals. If you’re paying $400 monthly on a personal loan instead of investing that money, you’re missing out on potential compound growth that could add up to thousands of dollars over time.

Alternatives worth considering first

Before taking out a personal loan, exhaust other options:

• Can you negotiate a payment plan directly with the creditor or service provider? Many medical providers, in particular, offer interest-free payment arrangements. Can you cut expenses temporarily to save up for the purchase or to build an emergency fund?

• If you have good credit, a 0% APR balance transfer credit card can be better than a personal loan for debt consolidation, provided you can pay off the balance during the promotional period (typically 12-21 months). Just watch out for balance transfer fees, usually 3-5% of the amount transferred.

• For homeowners with equity, a home equity loan or HELOC typically offers lower interest rates than personal loans. However, you’re converting unsecured debt into debt secured by your home, which means you could lose your house if you default. This added risk requires careful consideration.

• Borrowing from family or friends can avoid interest entirely, but it comes with relationship risks. If you go this route, treat it as seriously as a bank loan with a written agreement specifying terms and a clear repayment schedule.

Making a personal loan work in your favor

If you decide a personal loan is the right choice, approach it strategically.

1. Shop around aggressively—interest rates can vary by several percentage points between lenders. Check with credit unions, which often offer lower rates than banks or online lenders, especially if you’re already a member.

2. Pre-qualify with multiple lenders to compare offers without hurting your credit score. Most lenders offer pre-qualification that uses a soft credit pull, which doesn’t affect your credit. Only when you formally apply does the hard inquiry occur.

3. Choose the shortest loan term you can afford. While longer terms mean lower monthly payments, they also mean paying significantly more in interest over the life of the loan. A $10,000 loan at 12% APR costs about $1,300 in interest over three years but about $2,600 over five years.

4. Set up automatic payments to ensure you never miss a due date. Payment history is the single most important factor in your credit score. Some lenders even offer a small interest rate discount for enrolling in autopay.

The bottom line

The real question isn’t whether personal loans are good or bad, but whether borrowing money makes sense for your specific situation. Before signing on the dotted line, ask yourself: Is this loan solving a problem or creating one? Am I borrowing out of necessity or convenience? Do I have a realistic plan to repay this debt without borrowing again?

If you’re using a personal loan to dig yourself deeper into debt or to fund purchases you can’t afford, it’s a bad financial decision regardless of the interest rate. But if you’re using it strategically to consolidate expensive debt, manage a genuine emergency, or invest in your future in a calculated way, a personal loan can be a valuable tool that actually improves your financial position.

There’s always JG Wentworth…

Do you have $10,000 or more in unsecured debt? If so, there’s a good chance you’ll qualify for the JG Wentworth Debt Relief Program.* Some of our program perks include: 

• One monthly program payment 

• We negotiate on your behalf 

• Average debt resolution in as little as 48-60 months 

• We only get paid when we settle your debt