On this page
What's next
Earn a high-yield savings rate with JG Wentworth Debt Relief
How is Debt Counseling Different from Debt Settlement?
by
JG Wentworth
•
October 31, 2025
•
12 min
This information is provided for educational and informational purposes only. Such information or materials do not constitute and are not intended to provide legal, accounting, or tax advice and should not be relied on in that respect. We suggest that You consult an attorney, accountant, and/or financial advisor to answer any financial or legal questions.
When facing overwhelming debt, people often encounter two common solutions: debt counseling and debt settlement. These terms are frequently confused or used interchangeably, leading to significant misunderstandings about their purposes, processes, and outcomes. The critical question many people ask is whether debt counseling serves as a method of avoiding debt settlement, or whether these two approaches function as part of a unified strategy.
The answer is nuanced: debt counseling and debt settlement are fundamentally different solutions designed for different financial situations, though they may occasionally intersect in a comprehensive debt relief plan. Let’s take a closer look and break it all down…
Understanding debt counseling
Here are the basic elements of debt counseling:
- Debt counseling, also known as credit counseling, is a service typically provided by nonprofit organizations aimed at helping consumers understand their financial situation and develop a sustainable plan to manage their debt.
- Credit counselors are trained professionals who work with individuals to assess their complete financial picture, including income, expenses, assets, and outstanding debts.
- The primary goal of debt counseling is educational and organizational. When you work with a credit counselor, they review your budget, identify areas where you might reduce expenses, and help you understand how debt works, including interest rates, minimum payments, and the long-term implications of various repayment strategies.
- One of the most common outcomes of debt counseling is enrollment in a debt management plan (DMP). A DMP is a structured repayment program where the credit counseling agency works with your creditors to negotiate lower interest rates, waive fees, and establish a consolidated monthly payment. You make one payment to the counseling agency, which then distributes the funds to your creditors according to the negotiated terms.
- Importantly, under a debt management plan, you typically pay back 100% of what you owe. The benefit comes from reduced interest rates and fees, which can save you thousands of dollars over the life of the debt and help you become debt-free faster—usually within three to five years. Your accounts are closed as part of the DMP, and you agree not to take on new credit while enrolled in the program.
- Debt counseling services are generally low-cost or free for the initial consultation, with modest monthly fees (typically $25-$50) if you enroll in a DMP. Reputable credit counseling agencies are accredited by organizations like the National Foundation for Credit Counseling (NFCC) or the Financial Counseling Association of America (FCAA).
Understanding debt settlement
Debt settlement, also called debt negotiation or debt resolution, is a fundamentally different approach to addressing debt problems. Rather than paying back everything you owe with reduced interest, debt settlement involves negotiating with creditors to accept less than the full balance as payment in full.
The debt settlement process typically works as follows:
- You either work with a debt settlement company or negotiate on your own to convince creditors that you cannot pay the full amount owed.
- The settlement company usually advises you to stop making payments to your creditors and instead deposit money into a dedicated savings account.
- As your accounts become increasingly delinquent and creditors become more concerned about recovering any money, the settlement company negotiates offers, typically ranging from 25% to 50% of the original balance.
- Once a creditor agrees to a settlement amount, you pay that lump sum (or sometimes a few payments) from your accumulated savings account, and the creditor agrees to forgive the remaining balance. The goal is to resolve your debts for significantly less than what you originally owed.
Debt settlement companies typically charge fees ranging from 15% to 25% of the enrolled debt or the amount saved through settlement. These fees are usually paid out of your savings account once settlements are reached. The entire process can take two to four years, depending on how quickly you accumulate funds and how willing creditors are to negotiate.
It’s crucial to understand that debt settlement has serious consequences. During the months or years when you’re not paying your creditors, your credit score will plummet. You’ll face collection calls, potential lawsuits, and your accounts will be charged off. The forgiven debt may also be considered taxable income by the IRS, creating an unexpected tax bill. Additionally, there’s no guarantee that all creditors will agree to settle, leaving you in a worse position than when you started.
Take your next step towards being debt-free
"*" indicates required fields
How counseling can help you avoid settlement
Debt counseling functions as a preventive measure that can help consumers avoid the need for debt settlement altogether. This is perhaps the most important distinction between the two approaches: debt counseling is proactive and preservative, while debt settlement is reactive and a more destructive.
- More options: When you engage with a credit counselor early in your financial struggles—before accounts become seriously delinquent—you have more options available. The counselor can help you understand whether you have sufficient income to manage your debts with some modifications. If your situation is manageable, even if barely so, a debt management plan can provide the breathing room you need through lower interest rates and a structured payment schedule.
- Score survival: By entering a DMP, you avoid the credit score devastation that comes with debt settlement. While enrolling in a DMP may have a minor initial impact on your credit score (since accounts are typically closed), you’ll be making consistent, on-time payments, which is the most important factor in credit scoring. As you pay down your balances, your credit score can actually improve over time.
- Education: Debt counseling also provides something debt settlement cannot: financial education. Credit counselors teach budgeting skills, help you understand the root causes of your debt problems, and provide tools to avoid falling back into debt after you’ve paid off your current obligations. This educational component addresses the underlying behaviors that led to debt accumulation, making it a more sustainable long-term solution.
- Clarity: Furthermore, debt counseling can help you evaluate whether you’re actually a good candidate for debt settlement. Not everyone is. If your income is sufficient to meet your obligations with some adjustments, debt settlement would be an unnecessarily destructive choice. A credit counselor can provide an objective assessment of whether you need the drastic measure of settlement or whether less harmful alternatives exist.
When settlement might be considered despite counseling
While debt counseling aims to help people avoid debt settlement, there are circumstances where settlement might be the more realistic or appropriate option, even after consulting with a credit counselor. These situations typically involve severe financial hardship where the consumer simply cannot pay back all of their debt, even with reduced interest rates.
- If your debt-to-income ratio is extremely high—for example, if your total unsecured debt exceeds half of your annual income and you have limited prospects for income increase—a debt management plan may not be feasible. The monthly payments required, even with reduced interest, might still exceed what you can reasonably afford while covering basic living expenses.
- If you’re facing potential bankruptcy you might also consider debt settlement as an intermediate option. While bankruptcy provides a legal process for discharging debts, it has its own severe consequences and costs. Some people prefer to attempt debt settlement first, seeing it as less drastic than bankruptcy, though this decision should be made carefully with professional guidance.
- Medical debt presents another scenario where settlement might be appropriate. Medical bills often accumulate quickly and unexpectedly, creating debt loads that bear no relationship to the person’s income or ability to pay. Many medical providers are willing to negotiate settlements because they understand the circumstances and want to recover something rather than nothing.
It’s worth noting that some credit counseling agencies can provide guidance on debt settlement strategies or refer you to reputable settlement services if they determine you’re not a good candidate for a DMP. In this way, debt counseling can serve as a gateway to settlement when necessary, ensuring that settlement is chosen as a deliberate, informed decision rather than a desperate last resort.
The importance of timing and early intervention
One of the strongest arguments for seeking debt counseling early—and viewing it as a method to avoid debt settlement—is the importance of timing in debt management. The earlier you address debt problems, the more options you have available and the less damage you’ll sustain.
When you first notice that you’re struggling to make minimum payments or relying increasingly on credit cards to cover basic expenses, that’s the ideal time to consult a credit counselor. At this stage, your accounts are still current, your credit score is likely still reasonable, and creditors view you as a responsible borrower experiencing temporary difficulties. This puts you in a strong position to negotiate better terms through a DMP.
If you wait until accounts are seriously past due, collections agencies are calling, or lawsuits have been filed, your options narrow considerably. At this point, debt settlement might be your only realistic alternative to bankruptcy. The damage to your credit has already been done, and creditors are less willing to work with you on manageable repayment plans because you’ve already demonstrated an inability or unwillingness to pay.
Early intervention through debt counseling also helps you avoid the psychological stress and emotional toll that comes with mounting debt. The longer you wait, the more overwhelming the situation becomes, potentially affecting your mental health, relationships, and job performance. Credit counselors can provide not just financial strategies but also emotional support and encouragement during a difficult time.
Making an informed decision: questions to ask yourself
Determining whether debt counseling can help you avoid debt settlement—or whether settlement might be necessary despite counseling—requires honest self-assessment. Here are critical questions to consider when evaluating your situation:
- Can you afford to pay back what you owe with interest rate reductions? If your income, minus essential living expenses, can cover reasonable monthly payments that would eliminate your debt in three to five years, you’re likely a good candidate for a debt management plan through credit counseling. If the math simply doesn’t work even with zero interest, settlement or bankruptcy might be more realistic.
- How urgent is your situation? If creditors have already charged off your accounts, sent them to collections, or filed lawsuits, you may have missed the window where a DMP would be effective. In these cases, debt settlement or bankruptcy might be your only remaining options.
- What caused your debt problems? If your debt resulted from a temporary setback like job loss or medical emergency, and you now have stable income, debt counseling and a DMP can help you recover. If your debt resulted from chronic overspending or income that’s insufficient for your lifestyle, you need both the debt solution and significant behavioral changes that counseling can help provide.
- How important is protecting your credit score? If you need to maintain decent credit for employment, housing, or other important reasons, avoiding debt settlement becomes crucial. A DMP through credit counseling does much less damage to your credit than settlement.
- Do you have assets to protect? If you own a home, have retirement savings, or possess other significant assets, working with a credit counselor to find alternatives to settlement might protect these assets from potential creditor actions that could occur during the settlement process.
The bottom line
Debt counseling and debt settlement are not variations of the same strategy, nor does one simply function as an avoidance mechanism for the other. They are fundamentally different approaches designed for different levels of financial distress. Debt counseling, through education and structured repayment plans, serves as an early intervention tool that can indeed help consumers avoid the need for the more drastic measure of debt settlement.
The ideal approach is to seek debt counseling early, before your situation deteriorates to the point where settlement becomes necessary. By working with a reputable nonprofit credit counseling agency, you gain access to education, objective advice, and solutions that can help you avoid the destructive path of debt settlement. If settlement does become necessary, that same counselor can help ensure you approach it as an informed decision rather than a desperate gamble.
Ultimately, the relationship between debt counseling and debt settlement is less about one avoiding the other and more about using professional guidance to choose the right tool for your specific circumstances.
There’s always JG Wentworth…
Do you have $10,000 or more in unsecured debt? If so, there’s a good chance you’ll qualify for the JG Wentworth Debt Relief Program.* Some of our program perks include:
- One monthly program payment
- We negotiate on your behalf
- Average debt resolution in as little as 48-60 months
- We only get paid when we settle your debt
If you think you qualify for our program, give us a call today so we can go over the best options for your specific financial needs. Why go it alone when you can have a dedicated team on your side?
About the author
Recommended reading for you
* Program length varies depending on individual situation. Programs are between 24 and 60 months in length. Clients who are able to stay with the program and get all their debt settled realize approximate savings of 43% before our 25% program fee. This is a Debt resolution program provided by JGW Debt Settlement, LLC (“JGW” of “Us”)). JGW offers this program in the following states: AL, AK, AZ, AR, CA, CO, FL, ID, IN, IA, KY, LA, MD, MA, MI, MS, MO, MT, NE, NM, NV, NY, NC, OK, PA, SD, TN, TX, UT, VA, DC, and WI. If a consumer residing in CT, GA, HI, IL, KS, ME, NH, NJ, OH, RI, SC and VT contacts Us we may connect them with a law firm that provides debt resolution services in their state. JGW is licensed/registered to provide debt resolution services in states where licensing/registration is required.
Debt resolution program results will vary by individual situation. As such, debt resolution services are not appropriate for everyone. Not all debts are eligible for enrollment. Not all individuals who enroll complete our program for various reasons, including their ability to save sufficient funds. Savings resulting from successful negotiations may result in tax consequences, please consult with a tax professional regarding these consequences. The use of the debt settlement services and the failure to make payments to creditors: (1) Will likely adversely affect your creditworthiness (credit rating/credit score) and make it harder to obtain credit; (2) May result in your being subject to collections or being sued by creditors or debt collectors; and (3) May increase the amount of money you owe due to the accrual of fees and interest by creditors or debt collectors. Failure to pay your monthly bills in a timely manner will result in increased balances and will harm your credit rating. Not all creditors will agree to reduce principal balance, and they may pursue collection, including lawsuits. JGW’s fees are calculated based on a percentage of the debt enrolled in the program. Read and understand the program agreement prior to enrollment.
This information is provided for educational and informational purposes only. Such information or materials do not constitute and are not intended to provide legal, accounting, or tax advice and should not be relied on in that respect. We suggest that you consult an attorney, accountant, and/or financial advisor to answer any financial or legal questions.